Mon August 4, 2014
Where The Wild Things Play
Originally published on Tue August 5, 2014 7:38 am
This week, NPR Ed is focusing on questions about why people play and how play relates to learning.
Braden Swenson wanders into a semi-rickety wooden shed on his search for gold, treasure and riches.
"Is there any tweasure in here?" he asks in the endearing dialect of a 4-year-old. "I've been looking everywhere for them. I can't find any." The proto-pirate toddler conducts a quick search, then wanders away to continue his quest elsewhere.
Not far away, Ethan Lipsie, age 9, clutches a framing hammer and a nine-penny nail. He's ready to hang his freshly painted sign on a wooden "fort" he's been hammering away on. It says, "Ethan, Hudson and William were here."
"There's a lot of things that kids built," he explains, looking around at the playground. "It's not adults doing work; it's kids doing work!"
That could almost be the motto for the Adventure Playground. This half-acre of dirt and quirky chaos hugging the Berkeley Marina on San Francisco Bay is ranked among the most innovative and creative places for kids to play in the U.S.
It's got a semi-orderly, beachside junkyard feel. Nothing fancy or slick. Grab a bucket and brush: Kids can paint on almost anything here, except each other. Grab some wood and nails; it's hammer time.
Parker Swenson, 12, and his 7-year-old cousin, Tyler, have spotted some long tubes of sturdy plastic. "I dare you to go inside one and I'll push you down the slide."
"Yeah!" Tyler yells.
They climb in: The tubes are perfect for barreling down the modest hill here into the dirt below.
"Whoa, that was so awesome! I'm going again," yells Tyler.
There are only a handful of these "wild playgrounds" in the country. They embrace the theory that free, unstructured play is vital for children and offer an antidote to the hurried lifestyles, digital distractions and overprotective parents that can leave children few opportunities to really cut loose.
"It's really central that kids are able to take their natural and intense play impulses and act on them," says Dr. Stuart Brown, a psychologist and the founding director of the National Institute for Play.
Children need an environment with "the opportunity to engage in open, free play where they're allowed to self-organize," he adds. "It's really a central part of being human and developing into competent adulthood."
Brown says this kind of free-range fun is not just good; it's essential. Wild play helps shape who we become, he says, and it should be embraced, not feared.
Some educators advocate "dangerous play," which they say helps kids become better problem solvers.
In Europe there are lots of these kinds of free-range public playgrounds. They flourished after World War II. Europeans more readily embraced spaces for children to engage in what developmental psychologists like to call "managed risk."
But in the U.S. today there are barely a half-dozen. There are the Anarchy Zone in Ithaca, N.Y., which is just two years old, and a handful of others including a few in New York City.
This one in Berkeley is run by the city's parks and recreation department. It's funded largely by docking fees from the adjacent marina.
But, in many ways, this is Patty's place. "I've been involved here at the adventure playground since its inception — about 35 years," says Patty Donald, the playground's longtime coordinator.
Donald has been on a crusade to promote kid-driven, hands-on play. "A lot of people learn by touching and feeling and doing, and they excel that way," she says. "People drive two, three hours to come here."
Five staff members handle everything from replenishing the zip line's dirt landing zone to facilitating wood-painting and other play activities.
They keep a careful — yet mostly distant — eye on the children and what they're doing. If kids turn in wood with splinters or with a nail sticking out — called a "Mr. Dangerous" — they can earn paint and tools.
"You got it! Yay, Aly!" one staffer yells to a young girl as she makes her way across an old surfboard precariously balanced on a barrel.
The Cellphone Problem
So ... why are there so few of these wild playgrounds in the U.S.?
Fear of litigation is certainly an issue. But there are other factors, too, experts say. Among them are safety-obsessed, overprotective parents shepherding hyperscheduled children, and the fact that in America's cities and suburbs, play itself is in decline.
Donald worries that today's kids are controlled, coddled — and overscheduled. And some parents, she says, are often too distracted. "I find there are a lot of adults who don't know how to play with their kids."
Wait a minute, I ask: What do you mean there are parents who don't know how to play with their kids? I'm imagining awkward, distracted parents, fiddling with their iPhones because they don't get that they can actually interact with their children.
"Probably 75 percent of the parents that come in do that," Donald says. "The cellphone probably is the biggest problem we have. The parents are standing here, they're physically here."
But ... they're not really present, she says.
'Like A Pillow'
"This is awesome; this is a neat little place," says Dave Davirro. He and his 11-year-old son, Nicholas, are in from Hawaii visiting relatives in California.
He says kids need more places like this. "They're tearing down swings in my city," because they're dangerous, Davirro says. "We're way overprotective. I want my child to experience that, you know, there is some danger in everything."
Right now, father and son are checking out the zip line. It's a huge draw at the Adventure Playground, and the rule is kids go first.
Any child over 6 can just let it rip, sliding right into a pile of dirt. "You know, to fall in the dirt like this is just great!" says Davirro.
At its apex, the line is about 8 or 9 feet off the ground. There's no net.
I cautiously climb the zip line's wooden ladder to a waiting area that's kind of like the crow's nest of a ship.
It overlooks the bay, all blue, calm and sunshine this day.
But the kids up here are not taking in the view. All eyes are on me. Six-year-old Rhiannon Edison seems annoyed that an adult is encroaching on the Good Ship Zip Line.
"Wait, why are you here?" Edison asks skeptically.
I tell them I'm here to do a story on the playground. The kids nod. The adult with the fuzzy microphone can stay. For now.
I ask them what they like about this place, and get a host of answers:
"The zip line."
"It's nice how you can build your own things."
"I like how you can land in the dirt, but the dirt is really soft. It's so soft that it just feels like a pillow to me."
Enough talk — one of them zips away, down into that soft pile of sand.
Now it's my turn. With all my recording gear, what could possibly go wrong? I ask a little girl, a zip line pro, for advice.
"Point your feet towards the dirt so that the sand doesn't get in your underwear" she says, adding, "and have fun."
The kids give me a bon voyage countdown in unison. Swoosh.
The ride is quick, fast and fun. My recording gear gets a little sandy and roughed up, like it used to when I was reporting from the Middle East. Don't tell the NPR engineering shop, but I just might have to ride that zip line again.
MELISSA BLOCK, HOST:
In this part of the program, we're going to play - or at least talk about why play is important. It's the subject of a new series the NPR Ed team is kicking off today. Let's start with free and unstructured play. It's vital for children. Research shows a connection between play and kids' social, emotional and cognitive development. But play time in America's cities are in decline. Hurried lifestyles, digital distractions and overprotective parents have all helped create what some are calling a national play crisis. NPR's Eric Westervelt takes us to Berkeley, California, and one of the few adventure playgrounds in the nation.
ERIC WESTERVELT, BYLINE: Nine-year-old Ethan Lipsie clutches a framing hammer and a nine-penny nail. He's ready to hang his freshly painted sign on a wooden fort.
ETHAN LIPSIE: It says, Ethan, Hudson and William were here. There's a lot of things that kids built - and that kids built, not adults doing work. It's kids doing work.
WESTERVELT: That could be the motto of Berkeley's Adventure Playground. There's a semi-orderly, beachside, junkyard feel here - nothing fancy or slick. It's a half-acre of dirt and quirky chaos hugging the Berkeley Marina on San Francisco Bay. Kids grab a bucket and brush. You can paint on almost anything here, except each other. Grab some wood and nails. It's hammer time.
PARKER SWENSON: I dare you to go inside one and I'll push you down the slide.
TYLER SWENSON: Yeah.
WESTERVELT: Twelve-year-old Parker Swenson and his 7-year-old cousin, Tyler, eye the long, blue, plastic tubes. They climb inside, perfect for barreling down the hill here into the dirt.
T. SWENSON: Whoa. That was so awesome. I'm going again.
WESTERVELT: Nearby, 4-year-old Braden Swenson wanders into an improvised wooden shed continuing his exhaustive search for gold and treasure.
BRADEN SWENSON: Is there any treasure in here? I'm looking everywhere for them. And I can't find any. Is there any around here anywhere?
WESTERVELT: In an era of padded playgrounds and helicopter parenting, the Berkeley Adventure Playground stands out. In less litigious Europe there are lots of these kinds of free-range public playgrounds. They flourished after the Second World War. Europeans more readily embraced spaces for children to engage in what developmental psychologists call managed risk. But in the U.S. today there are barely half-a-dozen adventure-style public playgrounds. There's the relatively new Anarchy Zone in Ithaca, New York and a handful of others. Berkeley's place is run by the city's Parks and Recreation Department. But in many ways, this is Patty's place.
PATTY DONALD: My name is Patty Donald and I've been involved here at the Adventure Playground since its inception - about 35 years.
WESTERVELT: The playground's coordinator has been on a near four-decade long crusade to promote kid-driven, hands-on play.
DONALD: A lot of people learn by touching and feeling and doing. And they excel that way. People drive two, three hours to come here.
WESTERVELT: Staffers and parents keep a careful, yet mostly distant, eye on it all. If kids turn in wood with splinters or with a nail sticking out - called a Mr. Dangerous - they can earn paint and tools.
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON: Yay. Good job, Aly.
WESTERVELT: Five full-time staff members handle everything from restocking the zip line's dirt landing zone to facilitating occasional wood paint and play activities. Here kids have to talk to each other, problem-solve, and they get messy together. The Kids-first zip line is a huge draw. Any child over 6 can just let it rip into a pile of dirt. There's no net. At its apex, the line is about eight feet off the ground.
UNIDENTIFIED BOY: You want to go?
WESTERVELT: I climb up the zip line's wooden ladder to a crowded crow's nest-like perch waiting area. It overlooks the bay, all blue, calm and sunshine on this day. But the kids aren't taking in the view. All eyes are on me. Six-and-a-half-year-old Rhiannon Edison seems annoyed that an adult is encroaching on the Good Ship Zip Line.
RHIANNON EDISON: Wait, why are you here?
WESTERVELT: Why am I here? It's a good question. I'm doing a story on playgrounds and play and Adventure Playground.
WESTERVELT: The kids give each other semi-reassuring nods. The adult with the fuzzy microphone can stay for now. I asked them a simple question. What do you like about this place?
UNIDENTIFIED GIRL: I like the zip line. I like how it's very kid-ish. I like how you can just paint on anywhere. It's very fun.
EDISON: And I like how, like, you land in the dirt but the dirt's really soft. It's so soft that it just feels kind of like a pillow to me.
UNIDENTIFIED GIRL 2: It's nice that you can build your own things.
UNIDENTIFIED GIRL: I like how it seems like a kid made this whole place but it's just all, like, safe.
WESTERVELT: Then one of them zips away into that pile of soft sand.
DAVE DAVIRRO: You know, to fall in the dirt like this is just great.
WESTERVELT: Dave Davirro and his 11-year-son old son, Nicholas, are in from Hawaii visiting relatives. They're tearing down swings, and my city is dangerous, Dave says, shaking his head, adding, they won't even let kids drink out of a hose anymore.
DAVIRRO: We're way overprotective. I want my child to experience things. You know, there is some danger in everything, you know. This is awesome. This is a neat little place.
WESTERVELT: This isn't some Baby Boomer nostalgia for an imagined past when a play in the woods or vacant lot ethos ruled. The fact is, play is in trouble. Recess time around the nation has been trimmed. And after school play is now far more structured and controlled. Psychologist Doctor Stuart Brown is the founding director of the National Institute for Play. He says this kind of free-range fun is not just good, it's essential.
STUART BROWN: It's really central that kids are able to take their natural and intense play impulses and act on them and find in the environment the opportunity to engage in open, free play where they're allowed to self-organize. And it's really essential part of being human and developing into competent adulthood.
WESTERVELT: Adventure Playground coordinator Patty Donald worries that today's kids are controlled, coddled and overscheduled. And some parents, she says, are often too distracted to actively engage.
DONALD: I find that there's a lot of adults that don't know how to play with their kids.
WESTERVELT: Wait a minute. What do you mean there are parents who don't know how to play with their kid? Just awkward and playing on their iPhones and were, like, don't get that they can actually interact with their children?
DONALD: Probably 75 percent of the parents that come in do that. The cell phone probably is the biggest problem that we have here - is that parents are standing here, they're physically here.
WESTERVELT: But she says they're not really present.
UNIDENTIFIED PERSON: Attention Adventure Playground it is now time to hand in all tools and paint. Please bring them up to the front tool counter.
WESTERVELT: OK, enough work. It's time to play. I'm going to ride the zip line while recording myself. What could possibly go wrong? Any advice?
EDISON: Point your feet towards the dirt so that the sand doesn't get in your underwear. Hope you have fun.
WESTERVELT: All right. Thanks, man.
UNIDENTIFIED CHIDLREN: One, two, three. Go.
WESTERVELT: Eric Westervelt, NPR News Berkeley adventure playground. Whoa. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.