Exposure to lead as a child can affect an adult decades later, according to a study out Tuesday that suggests a link between early childhood lead exposure and a dip in a person's later cognitive ability and socioeconomic status.
Lead in the United States can come from lots of sources: old, peeling paint; contaminated soil; or water that's passed through lead pipes. Before policies were enacted to get rid of lead in gasoline, it could even come from particles in the fumes that leave car tailpipes.
And when lead gets into a human body, it can mess with brain development, decades of research has shown.
"It's toxic to many parts of the body, but in particular in can accumulate in the bloodstream and pass through the blood brain barrier to reach the brain," says the study's first author, Aaron Reuben, a graduate student in clinical psychology at Duke University.
Reuben and his colleagues published the results of a long-term study on the lingering effects of lead.
Researchers had kept in touch with about 560 people for decades — starting when they were born in Dunedin, New Zealand, in the 1970s, all the way up to the present.
As children, the study participants were tested on their cognitive abilities; researchers determined IQ scores based on tests of working memory, pattern recognition, verbal comprehension and ability to solve problems, among other skills.
When the kids were 11 years old, researchers tested their blood for lead. (That measurement is thought to be a rough indicator of lead exposure in the few months before the blood draw.)
Then, when they turned 38 years old, the cognitive ability of these study participants was tested again.
As Reuben and his colleagues write in this week's issue of JAMA, the journal of the American Medical Association, they found a subtle but worrisome pattern in the data.
As expected, the participants in the study who had low blood levels as children had an adult IQ that was as high as when they were kids.
However, Reuben says, children who experienced higher lead exposures "saw their intellectual abilities decline from their baseline starting point" as time wore on.
And, he adds, "people who saw that decline also experienced downward social mobility."
The children who'd had high lead exposure — defined at the time as more than 10 micrograms per deciliter of blood — were more likely than the other kids to go on to have jobs that required slightly less education and brought in a little less income compared to their parents' jobs.
In Reuben's study, every 5 microgram increase in lead concentration in the blood at age 11 corresponded to a drop in IQ of 1.6 points at age 38 — primarily because of a drop in scores on perceptual reasoning and working memory. (Today the health standards for lead are stricter; 5 micrograms per deciliter is considered high exposure, according to the Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, and no amount of lead is considered safe.)
The dips in IQ and in socioeconomic status were mild. But, Reuben says, "even small changes in IQ had some significant influence on the course that people's lives took."
There is one thin silver lining to the study, points out David Bellinger, a neuropsychologist and environmental epidemiologist with Boston Children's Hospital and Harvard Medical School and a longtime researcher of lead's effects: The findings lend credence to an estimate that, in the U.S. over the last 40 years, interventions to reduce lead exposure may have "raised the mean IQ in adults by as much as 4.5 points."
Still, Bellinger notes in an editorial accompanying the JAMA study that progress has not solved the problem.
There's no reason to think the findings in the New Zealand study wouldn't hold for an American population, too, he says — and they don't just apply to the generation now entering middle age.
Years after policies went into place in the U.S. limiting or eliminating lead in paint, plumbing and gasoline, there's still a lot of legacy lead hanging around, which kids can still ingest today.
"We will continue to have to deal with the impact of lead on children — and adults — until we address these legacy sources of lead that are still in our environment," Bellinger says.
And unlike in New Zealand, where lead exposure appears to have been an equal opportunity toxin — impacting all socioeconomic groups — in the U.S., children living in low-income areas tend to be most at risk.
"In Flint and other places we know now experiencing higher lead exposures than we would like, most of these kids are starting out already disadvantaged in life," Reuben says.
This study, he says, suggests that exposure to lead may be one more thing holding them back for decades to come.
KELLY MCEVERS, HOST:
One of the many concerns in Flint, Mich., is how lead exposure affects children. Research out today suggests children exposed to toxic lead feel the effects throughout their lives. As NPR's Rae Ellen Bichell reports, the study shows a link between childhood lead exposure and a dip decades later in a person's cognitive ability and socioeconomic status.
RAE ELLEN BICHELL, BYLINE: Lead can come from lots of places - from old paint, contaminated soil, from water that's passed through lead pipes. And Aaron Reuben says when that lead gets into a human body, it can mess with brain development.
AARON REUBEN: It's toxic to many parts of the body but in particular can accumulate in the bloodstream and pass through the blood-brain barrier to reach the brain.
BICHELL: Reuben is a graduate student in clinical psychology at Duke University. He and his colleagues just published the results of a big study on how lead exposure as a child can impact a person's life as an adult. The results are based on about 560 people. Researchers had kept in touch with them for decades from when they were born in Dunedin, New Zealand, in the 1970s until now.
When the people were children, researchers checked their blood for lead and gave them an IQ test. Then when they turned 38 years old, they got another IQ test. As Reuben and his colleagues wrote in the journal JAMA, they found a subtle but worrisome pattern. People who had low lead exposure as children had either the same or slightly higher IQ than they'd had as kids, but, Reuben says...
REUBEN: People who experienced higher lead exposures over time saw their intellectual abilities decline from their sort of baseline starting point, and people who saw that decline also experienced downward social mobility.
BICHELL: In other words, lead exposure seemed to continue to harm these people for decades after their childhoods. Reuben says the trends in IQ and socioeconomic status were mild, but...
REUBEN: Even small changes in IQ had some significant influence on the course that people's lives took.
BICHELL: In the U.S., it's been years since policies went into place limiting or eliminating lead in paint, plumbing and gasoline. But there's still a lot of legacy lead hanging around which kids can still ingest. And unlike in New Zealand where lead exposure appears to have impacted all socioeconomic groups, in this country, it's children living in low-income areas that tend to be most at risk.
REUBEN: Most of these kids are starting out already disadvantaged in life.
BICHELL: And he says this study shows exposure to lead may be one more thing holding them back for decades to come. Rae Ellen Bichell, NPR News.
(SOUNDBITE OF KENDRICK LAMAR SONG, "SING ABOUT ME, I'M DYING OF THIRST") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.