KTEP - El Paso, Texas

Landmark Report Concludes Abortion In U.S. Is Safe

Mar 16, 2018
Originally published on March 20, 2018 4:40 pm

Abortions in the United States are safe and have few complications, according to a landmark new study by the National Academies of Sciences, Engineering and Medicine.

The report, called "The Safety and Quality of Abortion Care in the United States," examined the four major methods used for abortions — medication, aspiration, dilation and evacuation, and induction — and examined women's care from before they had the procedure through their follow-up care.

"I would say the main takeaway is that abortions that are provided in the United States are safe and effective," says Ned Calonge, the co-chair of the committee that wrote the study. He is an associate professor of family medicine and epidemiology at the University of Colorado and CEO of The Colorado Trust.

Calonge says the researchers found that about 90 percent of all abortions happen in the first 12 weeks of pregnancy. And complications for all abortions are "rare," the report says.

But the report did find that state laws and regulations can interfere with safe abortions.

"Abortion-specific regulations in many states create barriers to safe and effective care," the report says.

Calonge says those rules often have no basis in medical research.

"There are some requirements that require clinicians to misinform women of the health risks, that say you have to inform a woman that an abortion will increase her risk of breast cancer," he says.

There is no evidence that breast cancer follows abortion, for example, but five states require doctors to tell women there is a link, according to the Guttmacher Institute, a research group that focuses on reproductive and sexual health.

"There are policies that mandate clinically unnecessary services like pre-abortion ultrasounds, separate inpatient counseling. There are required waiting periods," Calonge says.

According to Guttmacher, 27 states make women wait at least 24 hours for an abortion and 11 states require women to have an ultrasound before they can terminate their pregnancy.

And there are state laws that dictate who can perform abortions and where they can do them. Some require all abortions to happen in the equivalent of a hospital or surgery center. Others require a doctor to have admitting privileges at a nearby hospital.

The National Academies report says waiting periods and requirements for unnecessary tests can result in long delays because women may have to travel to get care and have trouble getting appointments.

"Delays put the patient at greater risk of an adverse event," the report says.

Hal Lawrence, the CEO of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists, says the report settles the debate over abortion-restricting laws and regulations.

"Those sorts of laws have been totally debunked," he says.

He says the study shows most of those laws do nothing to improve women's health.

"Abortion is safer when it's performed earlier in gestation," Lawrence says. "And so delaying and making people wait and go through hoops of unnecessary, extra procedures does not improve the safety. And actually by having them delay can actually worsen the safety."

The U.S. Supreme Court in 2016 voided some state abortion laws when it ruled that Texas' strict rules around abortion facilities impose an undue burden on women. But other laws remain in place even without any backing in medical research.

Still, Donna Harrison says there are good reasons for the requirements.

"The tendency to look at abortion as though it were not a serious medical procedure is irresponsible. I mean, we all know that the fetus is killed during an abortion but women can be harmed by irresponsible medical care," says Harrison, the executive director of the American Association of Pro-Life Obstetricians and Gynecologists.

She says data on complications from abortion is incomplete because doctors and patients don't always report it accurately, or at all.

"There is no good data collection — and when you have garbage in, and you have garbage out," she says.

And she says waiting periods are important so that women can give fully informed consent before they undergo what she says is a sometimes dangerous, surgical procedure.

The new report — which runs more than 200 pages — addresses most aspects of abortion care, including the use of the abortion pill mifepristone.

For example, it concludes that the strict requirements on how doctors can administer mifepristone may need review. The researchers say the rules may be erecting unnecessary barriers.

The report also says nurse practitioners and physician assistants can perform abortions just as safely as physicians.

Also, abortions have no long-term consequences on women's physical and mental health, the report says.

Copyright 2018 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

MARY LOUISE KELLY, HOST:

There's a new report out today on abortion safety and quality in the United States. It comes from the National Academy of Sciences. And it is the first time in more than 40 years the group has taken an in-depth look at the science. It finds high levels of safety for surgical and medical abortions. As NPR's Alison Kodjak reports, it concludes that many regulations states have imposed on abortion don't improve safety but instead create barriers to access and quality.

ALISON KODJAK, BYLINE: The researchers look at the four major methods used for abortions in the U.S. from the time before women get the procedure through their follow-up care. Ned Calonge is the co-chair of the committee that wrote the study.

NED CALONGE: I would say the main takeaway is that abortions that are provided in the United States are safe and effective.

KODJAK: Calonge is a family practitioner and professor of medicine at the University of Colorado in Denver. He says the study shows most abortions, about 90 percent, happen in the first 12 weeks of pregnancy. And he says complications are extremely rare. One of the biggest barriers to safe abortions, he says, are state laws and regulations that have no basis in medical research.

CALONGE: There are some requirements that require clinicians to misinform women of the health risks, that say you have to inform a woman that an abortion will increase her risk of breast cancer.

KODJAK: That rule exists in five states.

CALONGE: There are policies that mandate clinically unnecessary services like pre-abortion ultrasounds, separate inpatient counseling. There are required waiting periods.

KODJAK: Twenty-seven states make women wait at least 24 hours for an abortion, and 11 require women to have an ultrasound before they can terminate their pregnancy, according to the Guttmacher Institute, which does research on reproductive health. There are state laws that dictate who can perform abortions and where they can do them. And some require all abortions to happen in the equivalent of a hospital or surgery center. Others require a doctor to have admitting privileges in a nearby hospital.

HAL LAWRENCE: Those sorts of laws have been totally debunked.

KODJAK: That's Hal Lawrence, the CEO of the American College of Obstetricians and Gynecologists. He says the National Academy's report shows that most of those laws do nothing to improve women's health, and many of them just end up delaying when women get an abortion.

LAWRENCE: Abortion is safer when it's performed earlier in gestation. And so delaying and making people wait and go through hoops of unnecessary extra second procedures does not improve the safety and actually, by having them delay, can actually worsen the safety.

KODJAK: The Supreme Court in 2016 voided some state abortion laws when it ruled that Texas' strict rules around abortion facilities impose an undue burden on women. But other laws remain in place even without any backing in medical research. Donna Harrison is the executive director of the American Association of Pro-Life Obstetricians and Gynecologists. She says abortions should be treated like other surgical procedures with lots of oversight and regulation.

DONNA HARRISON: The tendency to look at abortion as though it were not a serious medical procedure is irresponsible. We all know that the fetus is killed during an abortion. But women can be harmed by irresponsible medical care.

KODJAK: The new report, which runs more than 200 pages, addresses most aspects of abortion care. Additional takeaways - nurse practitioners and physician's assistants can perform abortions just as safely as doctors, and women who get abortions show no negative long-term impact on their physical or mental health. Alison Kodjak, NPR News, Washington.

(SOUNDBITE OF APHEX TWIN'S "JYNWYTHEK YLOW") Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.