Author Interviews
12:46 am
Wed May 8, 2013

With Gorgeous Dorms But Little Cash, Colleges Must Adapt

Originally published on Thu May 9, 2013 9:43 am

Many high school seniors who are heading to college this fall have just paid their tuition deposits — the first real taste of what the college experience is going to cost them. These students are heading to school at a time that some consider a transformative moment for American colleges and universities. Costs are skyrocketing, and there are some real questions about what value college students are getting for their money.

Jeffrey Selingo is an editor with the Chronicle of Higher Education and author of a new book, College (Un)bound: The Future of Higher Education and What It Means for Students. In the book, he paints a picture of an American higher education system that has lost its way. Selingo joins NPR's David Greene to talk about palatial dorms, online courses and why colleges are no longer an equalizing force.


Interview Highlights

On why colleges are building fancy, resortlike dorms

"College now, today, has many jobs, right, and one of the jobs is maturing students and giving them kind of a comfortable place to live while they're going to school for four years. And so now we see, you know, these palatial dorms that have been built on many campuses — they have their own private bedroom and they share a kitchen and, you know, you go into a dining hall now and you have sushi in the dining hall. You have climbing walls, which I think everybody has, but now you even have these lazy rivers where you can get in an inner tube and go down. ...

"College presidents say that students and parents want this. But my contention is that if Harvard tomorrow decided to knock down all its residence halls and essentially build jail cells, do you think people would stop coming to Harvard? They'd probably keep going."

On how cash-strapped schools are struggling to pay for these luxuries

"Well, they ... [improved facilities] in the last decade when enrollment was going up, when money was free-flowing, you know. Most parents were using their homes as ATMs to pay for college, because of the housing market. And now suddenly those bills are coming due, and the problem is that the students are either not there or they're unwilling to pay the money to fund those things."

On the types of schools that are particularly trapped in an economic bind

"Most small, private liberal arts colleges in general. I mean, if you look at a map of the country, most of the private colleges in the U.S. are in the Midwest and the Rust Belt and the Northeast, where all the population growth, especially of 18-year-olds, [is in] the South and Southwest. And so part of the problem is that they're having a hard time just attracting students, because students have to fly halfway across the country to pay $50,000 for a degree that they're not quite sure what they're going to do with."

On what higher education will look like in the future

"I still think that colleges are still going to exist — physical college campuses are still going to exist for those who want it. What will be different, however, is that you're going to have many more players in the system. [For example] if you decide to take a MOOC [Massive Online Open Course] ... and you want to transfer credit ... MOOCs might provide a piece of a person's education.

"This idea of competency-based education, which I think is perhaps the most disruptive force potentially entering higher education — so, right now we measure learning by time spent in a seat. They test you on the way in, they see what you know, and you basically focus on what you don't know. What I think the disruption will be is that some students could finish in 2 1/2 years. There's nothing really magic about 120 credits in four years. It's just tradition."

On whether college still serves its traditional role of leveling the playing field and equalizing opportunities

"No, and that's really unfortunate. It was always seen as the great leveler in this country, especially after World War II. One of the most disturbing numbers I came across in research for this book was that if you come from a family with a family income above $90,000, you have a 1 in 2 chance of getting a bachelor's degree by the time you're in your mid-20s. If you come from a family under $35,000, you have a 1 in 17 chance.

"One of the fears, and one of my fears, is that we might become a country where the next generation is less educated than the generation that preceded it."

Copyright 2013 NPR. To see more, visit http://www.npr.org/.

Transcript

DAVID GREENE, HOST:

OK, this time of year, many high school seniors are thinking about what's next. Some aren't sure, some have jobs lined up, and others are set to go to college. And that last group may have already plunked down their tuition deposits, the first real taste of what the college experience is going to cost.

STEVE INSKEEP, HOST:

Tuition at many colleges and universities is sky-rocketing. We've talked about this on the program. People are doing the cost-benefit analysis and questioning what values students are really getting for all that money. There's also been a rise in online programs, for-profit universities and other alternatives, so colleges find themselves going to great lengths to attract students.

GREENE: Jeffrey Salingo is an editor with the Chronicle of Higher Education and also author of a new book, "College Unbound." He worries that American higher education has in some ways lost its way, and one symptom is the resources many schools are spending on campus amenities.

JEFFREY SALINGO: You go into a dining hall now and you have sushi in the dining hall. You have climbing walls, which I think everybody has. But now you even have these lazy rivers where you can get in an inner tube and go down a...

GREENE: And read and study while you're floating along the river.

SALINGO: Exactly.

GREENE: Well, where is the pressure coming from on colleges to do...

SALINGO: College presidents say that students and parents want this. But my contention is, is that if Harvard, tomorrow, decided to knock down all its residents' halls and essentially build jail cells, do you think people would stop coming to Harvard?

GREENE: They'd probably keep going.

SALINGO: They'd probably keep going.

GREENE: OK. We're talking about schools that are building climbing walls, at a time when a lot of schools are in a lot of debt and state funding for schools is going down. I mean, explain that for me.

SALINGO: Well, they did that in the last decade, when enrollment was going up, when money was free-flowing. You know, most parents were using their homes as ATMs to pay for college, because of the housing market. And now suddenly, those bills are coming due, and the problem is is that the students are either not there or they're unwilling to pay the money to fund those things.

GREENE: Give me a specific example of kind of a school that is caught in this economic bind that you described where it's hard to get out of.

SALINGO: Most small, private liberal arts colleges, in general, I mean, if you look at a map of the country, most of the private colleges in the U.S. are in the Midwest and the Rust Belt and the Northeast, where all the population growth, especially of 18-year-olds, are in the South and Southwest.

GREENE: OK.

SALINGO: And so part of the problem is that they're having a hard time just attracting students, because students have to fly halfway across the country to pay $50,000-plus for a degree that they're not quite sure what they're going to do with.

GREENE: You painted a picture of higher education and compared it to something like the auto industry in Detroit - that it's very resistant to change, but it's going to reach a point where it just has to accept that there is a new reality. If higher education goes through that process and emerges, what will be the same? What will be different?

SALINGO: I still think that colleges are still going to exist - physical college campuses are still going to exist for those who want it. What will be different, however, is that you're going to have many more players now in the system. If you decide to take a MOOC - for example - and you want to transfer credit...

GREENE: And this one is Massive Online Open Course. Right? Yeah.

SALINGO: Massive Online Open Course. Right. So MOOCs might provide a piece of a person's education. This idea of competency-based education, which I think is perhaps the most disruptive force potentially entering higher education.

GREENE: In this new world you suggested that if you, Jeffrey Selingo, you know, were looking for a job applicant and I was coming to you, I might be able to get some sort of credential from some online program that wasn't a college or a university.

SALINGO: Right.

GREENE: But if you accept that as sort of a legitimate credential, you could hire me and kind of keep colleges out of the process.

SALINGO: Right. Now I talked to some students who did that - who took some of these Massively Online Open Courses and one of them is working for Google right now. I mean the problem with that is that the best signal to the job market that you're ready still remains a college degree, and in my opinion will remain a college degree for the near future. But, as employers start - are not satisfied with some of the college graduates that they're hiring or they see others who are doing well based on their background, I think that we're going to start seeing employers look at alternative credentials - whether they're badges or certificates from other players beyond what we think of as traditional higher ed.

GREENE: Well, what can colleges do to convince students who are sitting there and saying, you know, I could take a massive online course, it's a lot cheaper than signing up for a four-year college degree? I mean what's the value of paying all of this money and going to one of these campuses still?

SALINGO: Well, and the value is, is really the one-on-one interaction with professors. I don't believe that we're suddenly in 10 years going to see thousands of colleges go out business and be replaced by online institutions. I'm also optimistic because some of the smartest most innovative people in this country live and work on college campuses, and that's why I think we still can figure it out. But the problem is that we have to move away from this hubris that I think higher education now has. They feel like we're a public trust; people will always want to get us as they're getting us now. I think those days are over and I think that colleges and universities need to think in new and different ways in order to prepare for the next 20-30 years.

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

GREENE: Jeffrey Selingo is the author of the new book, "College Unbound: The Future of Higher Education and What It Means for Students."

(SOUNDBITE OF MUSIC)

GREENE: And you're listening to MORNING EDITION from NPR News. Transcript provided by NPR, Copyright NPR.